AI Explainedby Milad Fahmy

AI Explained

Fine-tuning vs RAG: which one do you need?

Your AI doesn't know your company's docs. Fine-tune it, or use RAG? Short answer: RAG for knowledge, fine-tuning for behavior. Here's what the research says.

Milad FahmyNov 2, 20262 min read

On this page
  1. The two options
  2. For facts, RAG wins
  3. RAG's other advantages
  4. When fine-tuning wins
  5. Or do both
  6. A simple decision guide

Your AI doesn't know your company's docs. Should you fine-tune it, or use RAG? The short answer: RAG for knowledge, fine-tuning for behavior.

The two options

RAG (retrieval-augmented generation): before answering, your app searches your docs and puts the best matches in the prompt. The model's weights never change. RAG got its name in a 2020 paper from Facebook AI Research, which paired a model with a searchable index of Wikipedia.

Fine-tuning: more training. You show the model hundreds of examples, and its weights change.

For facts, RAG wins

A 2023 study (Ovadia et al.) compared both ways of teaching models facts. RAG "consistently outperforms" fine-tuning, both for knowledge the model had seen in training and for entirely new knowledge. The authors found models struggle to learn new facts through fine-tuning, and need many variations of the same fact to absorb it.

A 2024 study (Gekhman et al.) found something worse: new facts are learned slowly through fine-tuning, and as a model learns them, it tends to hallucinate more.

The takeaway: models mostly get their knowledge in pre-training. Fine-tuning teaches them how to use it.

RAG's other advantages

  • It stays fresh. Change a doc, and the next answer uses it. No retraining.
  • It shows sources. Users can check where the answer came from.

When fine-tuning wins

  • Style, tone or a strict format, every single time.
  • Teaching a small model one task, so it runs cheaper and faster than a big one.
  • Shorter prompts. The examples are baked in, so you don't send long instructions with every request.

Or do both

Fine-tune for the format, and use RAG for the facts.

A simple decision guide

You need… Use
Answers from your docs RAG
Up-to-date information RAG
Citations RAG
A consistent voice or format Fine-tuning
A cheap, fast model for one task Fine-tuning

Start with RAG and good prompts. Fine-tune only when the behavior still isn't right.

Facts in RAG, behavior in fine-tuning.

Sources

#fine-tuning#rag#llm#retrieval#hallucinations

Watch