AI Explained
Fine-tuning vs RAG: which one do you need?
Your AI doesn't know your company's docs. Fine-tune it, or use RAG? Short answer: RAG for knowledge, fine-tuning for behavior. Here's what the research says.
On this page
Your AI doesn't know your company's docs. Should you fine-tune it, or use RAG? The short answer: RAG for knowledge, fine-tuning for behavior.
The two options
RAG (retrieval-augmented generation): before answering, your app searches your docs and puts the best matches in the prompt. The model's weights never change. RAG got its name in a 2020 paper from Facebook AI Research, which paired a model with a searchable index of Wikipedia.
Fine-tuning: more training. You show the model hundreds of examples, and its weights change.
For facts, RAG wins
A 2023 study (Ovadia et al.) compared both ways of teaching models facts. RAG "consistently outperforms" fine-tuning, both for knowledge the model had seen in training and for entirely new knowledge. The authors found models struggle to learn new facts through fine-tuning, and need many variations of the same fact to absorb it.
A 2024 study (Gekhman et al.) found something worse: new facts are learned slowly through fine-tuning, and as a model learns them, it tends to hallucinate more.
The takeaway: models mostly get their knowledge in pre-training. Fine-tuning teaches them how to use it.
RAG's other advantages
- It stays fresh. Change a doc, and the next answer uses it. No retraining.
- It shows sources. Users can check where the answer came from.
When fine-tuning wins
- Style, tone or a strict format, every single time.
- Teaching a small model one task, so it runs cheaper and faster than a big one.
- Shorter prompts. The examples are baked in, so you don't send long instructions with every request.
Or do both
Fine-tune for the format, and use RAG for the facts.
A simple decision guide
| You need… | Use |
|---|---|
| Answers from your docs | RAG |
| Up-to-date information | RAG |
| Citations | RAG |
| A consistent voice or format | Fine-tuning |
| A cheap, fast model for one task | Fine-tuning |
Start with RAG and good prompts. Fine-tune only when the behavior still isn't right.
Facts in RAG, behavior in fine-tuning.